Welcome to The Slippery!
The Slippery
The Slippery
The Slippery exposes the scammers, schemers, and master manipulators behind some of the most audacious cons ever pulled off. Hosted by veteran true crime producers Nancy Moscatiello and Scott Eldridge, each case unfolds through gripping storytelling and insider perspective — revealing how deception thrives, and how it eventually unravels.
Choose your favorite podcast player
May 7, 2026

EP 8 | DEBRIEF: There's a Finger In My Chili

EP 8 | DEBRIEF: There's a Finger In My Chili

It was the "crunch" heard ‘round the world. In 2005, a bowl of chili in San Jose, California, became the center of a media firestorm that nearly toppled a fast-food empire. This week on The Slippery Debrief, Scott and Nancy are joined by the man who was in the trenches of the investigation: Detective Jose Martinez of the San Jose Police Department.

Detective Martinez walks us through the surreal journey of the "Chili Finger" case—an investigation that shifted rapidly from a public health nightmare to a high-stakes criminal hunt. We go behind the yellow tape to see how old-fashioned police work and modern science collided to expose a fraud that was as gruesome as it was calculated.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices